Ep. 351: Happy Halloween!

Posted on by Sara Fade

SPOILER ALERT: we like candy and guessed all of them.

🍕 Happy Halloween from the MCPL Podcast! Blindfolds, Candy, and Total Chaos 🍭

Hey there, candy fiends and Halloween lovers! đŸ‘»

We highly recommend you watch this week’s episode of the Middle Country Public Library Podcast—because this one? This one is visually chaotic in the best way. But if you’re just reading along or listening in the car (safely, we hope), don’t worry—we’ve got you.

This Halloween episode was extra special: it was our first-ever video Halloween special AND it featured a blind taste test of classic Halloween candy. Spoiler: it was as hilarious as it was sugary. 🍬

So picture this: Sal is dressed as a slice of pizza. Sara and Nicole are blindfolded and fumbling their way through a lineup of America’s most beloved (and occasionally controversial) candy bars. There are bowls, mystery treats, trivia, and a lot of, “Wait—what is this??”

Let’s break it down, candy by candy:

đŸ« 1. Kit Kat

We kicked things off easy. That iconic snap? Dead giveaway.

“Is it a Kit Kat?”
“Yup. Been training for this my whole life.”

Fun Fact: Kit Kat was invented in 1935 in England and later licensed in the U.S. by Hershey. Each piece is technically called a finger. You’re welcome.

đŸ„œ 2. Butterfinger

This one stirred a little controversy.

“They changed the recipe… it’s not as good anymore.”
“Not a big Butterfinger fan.”

Still, they guessed it instantly. Shout-out to Bart Simpson for making Butterfinger the candy of the ‘90s.

đŸ„œđŸ« 3. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup

The shape gave this one away immediately.

“Cheers… we both know what this is.”
“Reese’s. Mini, obviously.”

H.B. Reese, a former Hershey employee, started his own candy company in 1928… and then got bought right back into the Hershey fam. Classic.

😖 4. Sour Patch Kids

Sara almost guessed “Swedish Fish,” but that sour kick sealed the deal.

“Sour Patch Kids!”
“You know what they’re called in France? Very Bad Kids.”
“That’s amazing.”

Also, they were originally called Marsmen in the ‘70s. Wild.

đŸ„„ 5. Almond Joy

Cue the division.

“I don’t want it.”
“Why not?”
“Coconut. Nope.”

But Nicole took one for the team and guessed it right. Almond Joy: invented by six Armenian immigrants in 1919, loved by 80% of the U.S. military in the 1940s.

🌍 6. Snickers

Sal’s favorite—and a global best-seller.

“One, two, three…”
“Snickers!”

Did you know it was named after the Mars family’s favorite horse? That’s sweet… and also, slightly concerning. 🐮

đŸ« 7. Three Musketeers

A little confusion here:

“Milky Way?”
“Wait… no. Three Musketeers!”

Originally, these bars came with three flavors—chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry. That’s why they were called Three Musketeers. But sugar rationing during WWII left us with just chocolate.

đŸ„œ 8. Payday

The wildcard.

“It’s like peanut brittle? Not chocolatey…”
“PAYDAY!” 🎉

This old-school bar (introduced in 1932) ditches the chocolate for straight-up peanuts and caramel. There’s now a chocolate version too—because why not?

🍬 Final Thoughts: Sugar, Laughs, and a Whole Lotta Trivia

Throughout the episode, between bites and blindfolds, we dropped candy facts, nostalgia, and plenty of laughs. Sara and Nicole crushed the guessing game (even if coconut betrayed them), and we all left with a sugar high and newfound candy knowledge.

So whether you’re a Milky Way loyalist or a sour fiend, there’s one thing we can all agree on: Halloween is the perfect excuse to raid the candy aisle… for research purposes, of course.

Watch the full episode for the full visual chaos—and maybe grab a snack while you’re at it. 🍭

Happy Halloween from all of us at MCPL!

đŸŽƒđŸ‘»đŸŹ

Related Posts